Notes on Prog: Hobbits

How many hobbits are there in prog? This is a question brought to mind by a recent article inspired by the 30th anniversary of Marillion’s first album.  The article is thoughtful and funny, but, I think, rather wrong on a few counts.  Here’s one point I question:

And then there are the lyrics. Yeah… the lyrics. It’s a shame, albeit a little one, because one thing Marillion did have over the original proggers, I suppose, was their desire to sing about something recognisably real, rather than making like J.R.R. Tolkien in Rag Week…. taking instead more familiar themes: depression, alcoholism, drugs, heartbreak, isolation, cool stuff like that.

This sort of notion is far from unique to this article and is completely in line with the broader world of prog bashing.  But here it is yet again, and once again I ask myself: is it correct?

Tolkien in particular? Proggers aren’t the most obvious offenders.  Or let’s not be pedantic: sure there’s plenty of general medievalism and a few nixies as well.   Overall, however— and I don’t have a systematic accounting for this, I confess— sci-fi seems at least as well represented, with all the sky watchers and  starship troopers.   Those who care deeply about precisely how embarrassing their taste in music is will be better positioned to advise whether sci-fi is all that deprecated a genre in popular music outside the prog zone.

As far as “recognizably real,” two frequent purveyors come immediately to mind: Jethro Tull’s yippified but essentially British Kitchen Sink sarcastic (“write your will and testament, run for local government, we’ll have superman for president…) and Robert Wyatt’s gently surreal bohemian soap operas.

Tagged with: , ,
Posted in music
4 comments on “Notes on Prog: Hobbits
  1. Patrick M says:

    my goal is to make this blog about nothing but Prog Rock…and whatever else i throw out that deserves a jerky comment…well done….ok…i’m off to listen to Cliff Bennett…the man who WISHED he had joined Uriah Heep…

  2. jacksundance says:

    The very first thing I thought when I read the title was “Rivendell.” Love that old Rush. And oddly Zeppelin is the second thing I thought of…When I see the word ‘Hobbit’ I usually think of Zeppelin before I even think of Tolkien. haha! Yeah I think Zeppelin was pretty much the worst offender of all the genres…

  3. […] Good: Marillion’s Script For a Jester’s Tear” , the article I mentioned in an earlier post.  From that […]

  4. […] posts; the dislike seems more visceral than can be explained by trends in music criticism or a few Tolkien references.  My explanation for this reaction […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s